Politics Reports Trends

Why alarm bells should be ringing for Hillary Clinton in a key swing state


If Jefferson County Fair is anything to go by – Hillary Clinton has her work cut out for her this week.

It’s in full swing – pig racing, a demolition derby – hoedown tunes floating through the air from the fiddle competition. Sweltering in a heatwave, this is Grassroots Americana in a rural corner of Pennsylvania. It feels a million miles from Philadelphia across-state where the Democratic convention is underway.

And in a county which went strongly for Donald Trump and Bernie Sanders in the primaries – it has a searing message for Hillary Clinton: we don’t like you and we don’t want you, and even if we do give you our vote, it’s only because you’re the lesser of two evils.

So in a state which hasn’t voted for a Republican president since 1988, and where Hillary Clinton soundly beat Obama in the 2008 presidential primaries – where did it go wrong for her?

In the shade of a cattle barn, I chatted to some farmers and heard a whole host of reasons: trust, character, establishment politics – and – still – the fact she’s a woman.

Farmers Bill and Suzianne Smith are registered Democrats. Suzianne has grappled with her opinion of Hillary over many years – but is coming to the conclusion Clinton can’t be trusted.

Her husband is in no doubt though. Trump has his vote. He doesn’t like Clinton and reckons a female US president would be a disaster – articulating an opinion few are prepared to venture so frankly.

Pity the poor Democrat campaigners then who’ve now got to sell the Hillary ticket in a county full of Trump fans and Bernie-crats. Their tent at the fair has plenty of flags and fliers: but not a single image of Clinton to be seen.

Kerith Taylor is running for the Democrats for Congress – a Bernie backer who saw his vision for working class America as the way to go. But now, like him, she has to fall in behind Hillary – and it’s not easy. On the doorsteps of Jefferson County, she can’t even mention her name.

For women of a certain age in America, Clinton is a long yearned-for bullet for the toughest glass ceiling of all. She polls very well amongst them – in almost unassailable figures for Trump.

But this just hasn’t cut through to the younger generation of women – who are largely enjoying the benefits of the feminist struggle, and don’t see a woman running for president as a big deal. Millennial democrat women backed Bernie Sanders 61-31% over Clinton.

Sam Sears was one of them. She takes a break from singing at the fair to tell us she will now vote for Hillary – but reluctantly. It’s only because she loathes Trump.

There has always been a significant contingent in America with a visceral dislike for Hillary Clinton. But it’s astonishing to reflect that as Secretary of State she had a 66% approval rating – and went into the primaries with every reason to feel confident. And at this stage she is still ahead in the race.

But a perfect storm of personal controversy, voter rage against the establishment – and a Republican challenger who has ripped up the rule book has left Hillary Clinton looking vulnerable in a way few would ever have imagined.

In the hills of Jefferson County – the alarm bells are ringing.

  • Julie Etchingham


88 Total Views 1 Views Today

About the author

Sydney Chesterfield

Poet, Playwright, Philosopher, Humanitarian, mad lover of children and unflinching fighter for equality on all grounds viz. Women's rights, child rights, sine die.

Twitter: @syd_field